Cross-reactivity of EGFR mutation-specific immunohistochemistry assay in HER2 positive tumors

Verdu M1,2, Trias I1,2,3, Roman R1, Rodon N1, Pubill C2, Arraiza N2, Martinez B2, Garcia-Pelaez B1, Serrano T1,2,3, Puig X1,2,3.

1BIOPAT, Biopatologia Molecular SL, Grup Assistència, Barcelona, Spain. 2Histopat Laboratoris, Barcelona, Spain. 3Hospital de Barcelona-SCIAS, Grup Assistència, Barcelona. Spain.


The co-expression of HER2 and EGFR L858R in a solitary nodule removed from the lung, whose mutation was not confirmed by molecular techniques, made us think about the possible existence of a cross-reaction between HER2 and the EGFR L858R-specific antibody. Our study was designed to further analyze the existence of this cross-reaction and stress the need to exclude a metastatic breast cancer when dealing with EGFR L858R positive cases.

The series consists of 42 primary breast carcinomas, 22 HER2 positive for overexpression and amplification, and 20 negative for both. EGFR mutations were studied by immunohistochemistry and confirmed using real-time PCR when positive. Immunohistochemistry assay with EGFR L858R was positive in 19 (86%) of the HER2 positive breast carcinomas, and negative in all HER2 negative carcinomas.

Conclusions: The EGFR L858R antibody gives false positive results in most of the breast carcinomas with HER2 overexpression/amplification. As a consequence, it is essential to confirm any EGFR L858R positive cases by molecular methods or at least discard the presence of HER2 overexpression/amplification before rendering a diagnosis. It is also important to consider that HER2 has been described in other carcinomas as urothelial, gastric or ovarian, as well as lung although infrequently.

Key words: EGFR mutations; L858R; HER2; metastatic breast cancer; lung cancer.


Texto completo                                                          Appl Immunohistochem Mol Morphol. 2015 Sep;23(8):565-70.